Exploring Soft Enamel and Hard Enamel: Which is Best for Your Project?

When it comes to creating eye-catching and durable enamel pins or other metal products, choosing the right enamel finish is crucial. Two popular options in the world of enamel finishes are soft enamel vs hard enamel. Each offers distinct advantages and brings a unique aesthetic to your project.

In this blog post, we will explore the characteristics of soft enamel and hard enamel, helping you make an informed decision about which finish best suits your project’s requirements. Moreover, let us introduce a fantastic product idea for the upcoming holidays!

Enamel is a glassy, hard substance that protects materials from corrosion and increases their aesthetic value. It could be used in varnishes, paints, and coatings. After drying, enamel produces a solid and glossy finish—an enamel-like surface that has a bright lustre.

The Art of Enameling

Enamelling is a decorative process that can be used to produce high-quality colours and patterns on glass, ceramics and metal surfaces. It involves fusing powdered glass to a metal substrate at high heat. Enamel is composed of inorganic pigments and additives that each have various properties of opacity, translucent, and transparency. That composition will determine how the enamel is fired.

What is the difference between. . .

Soft Enamel

Soft enamelling involves adding enamel in the recessed areas of the material and baking it hard. Since the enamel is below the edges, you can feel the textured feel of the merchandise.

Hard Enamel

Hard enamelling is pouring enamel several times in the recessed areas of the material and heating it at a very high temperature. It is then polished smooth to ensure that the enamel is at the same level as the metal edges.

Advantages of Soft Enamel:

Texture and Depth

The raised metal edges and recessed enamel give soft enamel pins a tactile quality and a sense of depth, making them visually appealing.

Vibrant Colors

Soft enamel allows for a wide range of vibrant and vivid colours, making your design stand out.


Soft enamel is generally more affordable than hard enamel, making it a popular choice for those on a budget or looking to create larger quantities of pins.

Advantages of Hard Enamel:


Hard enamel pins are highly resistant to scratches, making them suitable for daily use and long-lasting wear.

Smooth and Shiny Finish

The polishing process gives hard enamel pins a smooth and glossy surface that reflects light beautifully, enhancing the overall visual impact of your design.

Prestigious Look

Hard enamel pins have a luxurious look and feel, making them a preferred choice for brands or projects aiming to convey a sense of quality and exclusivity.

Choosing the Best Finish for Your Project

When deciding between soft enamel and hard enamel, consider the following factors:

Design Complexity

Soft enamel is an excellent choice for designs that require intricate details or a textured appearance. The recessed areas of the metal base in soft enamel allow for greater depth, which can be effectively utilized to capture intricate patterns, fine lines, and subtle shading. The raised metal edges surrounding the enamel add a tactile element that enhances the overall visual appeal.

With its ability to showcase intricate details, soft enamel is often preferred for designs that feature complex artwork, such as portraits, landscapes, or intricate logos. The textured finish of soft enamel can bring depth and dimension to these designs, creating a visually striking and engaging result.

Here’s a closer look at the Christmas ornament concept made from soft enamel.

On the other hand, hard enamel excels in highlighting clean and minimalist designs. The process of adding multiple layers of enamel and polishing the surface creates a smooth, flat, and glass-like finish. This results in a pin with a sleek appearance and a flawless surface that reflects light beautifully.

Clean lines, bold shapes, and solid colours are particularly well-suited for hard enamel. The smooth surface of hard enamel provides a perfect canvas for showcasing simple yet impactful designs, such as company logos, symbols, or geometric patterns. The polished finish of hard enamel gives these designs a sophisticated and refined look that exudes a sense of elegance and professionalism.


Soft enamel is known for its cost-effectiveness, making it a popular choice, especially when producing larger quantities of enamel pins or metal products. The production process for soft enamel involves filling recessed areas with coloured enamel, which is then baked at a lower temperature. This process is relatively efficient and requires less labour and time compared to hard enamel production.

The cost-effectiveness of soft enamel arises from a few factors. Firstly, the materials used in soft enamel, such as the metal base and coloured enamel, are generally more affordable compared to those used in hard enamel production. Additionally, the simplified production process of soft enamel requires less intricate craftsmanship, resulting in lower labour costs.

When creating enamel pins in bulk, the cost savings of choosing soft enamel can be significant. The ability to produce a larger quantity of pins at a lower cost per unit makes soft enamel an attractive option for those working with tight budgets or looking to distribute pins as promotional items or merchandise.

Injecting soft enamel into a metal frame. After baking, the soft enamel will solidify.

On the other hand, hard enamel tends to be pricier due to its labour-intensive production process. Achieving a smooth, polished finish requires meticulous craftsmanship and additional steps, including multiple layers of enamel application and precision polishing. Each layer of enamel must be fired at high temperatures, resulting in a longer production timeline and increased labor costs.

The higher cost of hard enamel is also influenced by the materials involved. The enamel used in hard enamel production is typically of a higher quality and more expensive. Additionally, the polishing and buffing processes require specialized tools and expertise, further contributing to the overall cost.

While hard enamel may be more expensive, it offers a premium look and durability that can justify the investment for certain projects. For designs that require a high-end finish or are intended for long-term use, the extra cost of hard enamel may be worthwhile.

Intended Use

The durability of the enamel finish is an important consideration when choosing between soft enamel vs hard enamel, particularly if your pins will be subject to frequent handling or rough use. In such cases, hard enamel’s inherent resilience and toughness make it the more suitable option.

Hard enamel products undergo a rigorous production process that involves multiple layers of enamel being added and polished to create a smooth, glass-like surface. This results in an item that is highly resistant to scratches, fading, and general wear and tear. The hard enamel finish forms a protective layer over the design, ensuring that it remains intact even with frequent handling or exposure to harsh conditions.

If you anticipate that your products will be used as everyday accessories or attached to items that may experience rough use, such as backpacks or jackets, hard enamel’s durability becomes a significant advantage. Its ability to withstand the test of time ensures that your promotional items will retain their pristine appearance and continue to be enjoyed by their owners.

However, if you’re focused on creating a collection of unique designs that prioritize artistic expression and a textured look, soft enamel may be the better choice. Soft enamel products have a distinct visual appeal due to their raised metal edges and recessed enamel areas. This textured finish adds depth and character to the design, giving it a handcrafted and artistic feel.

Soft enamel ornaments are well-suited for display purposes, whether on a pinboard or as collectables. They often evoke a sense of nostalgia and craftsmanship, making them highly sought after by pin enthusiasts and collectors. Soft enamel’s ability to capture intricate details and provide a tactile experience further enhances the overall aesthetic appeal of these pins.

To Conclude,

Soft enamel vs hard enamel each offer distinct qualities that can enhance your project’s aesthetic and functionality. Understanding the differences between the two finishes will help you make an informed decision based on your design requirements, budget, and project goals. Whether you opt for the textured allure of soft enamel or the sleek elegance of hard enamel, both finishes have the potential to elevate your enamel pin or metal product to new heights of visual appeal.

What to Read Next?

How can you create your own display idea that will not only provide convenience to your customers but will also help your brand generate sales? Well, have you ever asked for help from experienced POS designers?

Luxury packaging can increase the perceived value of products. In other words, the more luxurious and elegant your wine packaging design looks, the more consumers will be willing to pay for it. Check out our packaging design concept here!

With the ever-changing trends, you must ensure that you are up-to-date and in the right direction. One of the best ways to do this is to get flat-pack products for marketing your company. Here’s our idea!

Modular POS is a great solution for retail spaces of all sizes, as it can be easily adapted to fit in any space. One design can be used for different retail spaces, which saves time and resources.

Minimalist product design has become extremely popular over the years because of its simplicity and how it can transform a product into a masterpiece. It makes the product more attractive, easy to use and increases its functionality.

No Comments

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.